"You look great," his tone was that of an old friend, rather than a lover. I felt my body strain forward searching for the old heat. When had it disappeared?
"Thanks," I had spent days agonizing over what to wear. Everything, from the pink lace bra to the strappy black sandals that crossed across my cherry red toenails was new and designed to show off a body newly tanned and toned.
I sent him a bright smile praying he wouldn't hear my pounding heart. With easy movements, I forced myself to lean back into my chair, the wicker pressing roughly into my arms.
I raised the glass to my mouth, willing my hands to stop shaking, and took a long sip. Icy vodka and cranberry juice slid down my throat. "So," I said, pretending that I didn't care, "what have you been up to?"
He leaned back, mirroring my pose. I kept the smile pasted on my face as he talked. Grateful that sunglasses hid my eyes, I drank him in, cataloging the changes.
I nodded my head and laughed at all the right times. I was the ideal ex-girlfriend, lightly flirting, no hint of desperation, teasing him about his dating life. I played my part perfectly.
Inside, beneath the nerves, anger boiled. Why? I pushed down the question bubbling to my lips. I took another drink to cool the anger, to show that I didn't care, to play the game I hated.
"And how have you been?" He looked suddenly serious. His tone strained. He feels guilty. Good.
I turned my smile up a notch, the brightness now vying a Vegas billboard. "I've been great!" I waved my hand. "Really busy." I prattled on, talking about friends and trips while he nodded. I wondered if he was studying me as I had studied him. If he'd noticed all the changes that six months of Wheat Thins and vodka, dancing and sunbathing had produced.
Our conversation faded to silence. We sat, looking out over the ocean. I thought of the speeches I'd written for this moment. The anger deep inside urged me to yell, scream, cause the scene he'd always avoided.
A cool breeze ruffled my hair, goosebumps popping up on my arms. He noticed. He always noticed the small discomforts. It was when big issues arose that he retreated and disappeared.
"It's getting late," he said, reaching for his wallet.
"It was great seeing you," I said, disappointed. Disappointed in myself for not saying what needed to be said. Disappointed in him for not acknowledging the hurt.
Walking across the parking lot, he tossed it out, almost as an afterthought. "I'm sorry for the way I did it. You deserved better. I should have been better. But you have to realize now it never would have worked."
The old lump lodged in my throat. My smile dimmed. He wrapped his arms around me, enveloping me in his scent and sending years of memories to drown me. I allowed myself to cling for a moment as his words hung in the air.
Stepping back, I channeled every ounce of the anger coursing through my blood, every night spent crying, every day spent as a ghost and clutched it, feeling it vibrate through my body, surging to the surface.
And then I released it, not in an explosion, but in a smile. Real now. He is who he is and he'll never change.
"We'll have to do this again," I said, lying. I straightened my shoulders, "I really need to go. I've got a date." I turned from the man I had planned to marry and walked away.
Forgiveness? It tasted like vodka, burning at first and then a smooth ride to warmth.
This post was inspired by The Red Dress Club Remembe(red) memoir prompt: forgiveness. For the record? That's a tougher prompt than you may think. And, per usual, concrit is always welcomed.
On an unrelated note, I'm also over at Makes Fun today giving away a book. And no. It's not a romance novel. Please. I keep all of those.
68 comments:
I like the line at the end "I have a date." An attempt to make him feel jealous?
I turned my smile up a notch, the brightness now vying a Vegas billboard. "I've been great!" I waved my hand. "Really busy." I prattled on, talking about friends and trips while he nodded. I wondered if he was studying me as I had studied him. If he'd noticed all the changes that six months of Wheat Thins and vodka, dancing and sunbathing had produced.
To me that paragraph said it all.
"Forgiveness? It tasted like vodka, burning at first and then a smooth ride to warmth." I loved, loved this line. it seals it all up, and I love how you used vodka to sum it up. I was sitting there with you, seeing him as you saw him, seeing you as you saw yourself....
It felt like a dance, the way you weaved back and forth between your emotions and what was happening. I want to dance like this again.
Ugh. His parting line tells it all. I hate the apology that is really kinda not. Yes, he would have never changed.
Not to harsh your forgiveness mellow or anything. I just don't like him at all based on that last bit.
The last line is amazing. I also loved the line about him noticing the goosebumps, and "every day as a ghost" is perfect as well.
For some reason that "Vegas" line about your smile took me away a bit.
Mandy, as always, you inspire.
A diet of wheat thins and vodka... shudder!
You've captured the role played here so well. So well that I'm trying to think of an ex to forgive so I can show off my toes in strapy sandals. And then, I realize it's March in New England, and I won't see my toes again for months...
The third paragraph reads a little run-on for me, but I think a comma, or a sentence break would solve that.
And your last line? I don't usually like wrap-up lines (though I'm guilty of them enough), but that one is killer!
Oh, good stuff.
I loved the last line and your descriptions made me feel as though I was right there through the whole thing.
I could really feel how uncomfortable you both were. Very well written.
I really liked this. My favorite part was where he finally threw in his attempt at apologizing. I especially liked the line with "sending years of memories to drown me," actually that whole sequence of you clinging, then summoning anger, then your realization is very powerful. It rings so true.
I kind of wish you'd told him to shove it, but then this wouldn't be appropriate for the forgiveness prompt!
Mandy, this was so well written. The imagery, the word choices, the emotion. Are all expertly woven together into this post.
I could feel her (your!) angst and when you let that go.
Word choices such as: "cool the anger" "the wicker pressing roughly into my arms" and "enveloping me in his scent and sending years of memories to drown me" really drew me in and kept me here. For every single word.
Oh.. that last line!
I have been in this situation before, I have sat across from an ex internally begging him to apologize, or ask me back, or tell me he misses me.
But then to learn that I was better off without him.
This really drew me in, took me on that dinner date with you.
And that last line!
Perfect!!
"But you have to realize now that it never would have worked."
What an ass. Even in a lame apology he can't take any responsibility. See, that's how wrapped up I got in just these few paragraphs. Complete picture painted well per usual my friend.
I'm with CDG on the third paragraph though. It doesn't flow as well as the rest of your story. Crossed and across, new and newly - how about - "My recent purchases, from the pink lace bra down to the black strappy sandals, were chosen with the intent to showcase the newly tanned and toned me."
Something like that :) Now excuse me while I go workout. "Toned" - what the hell is that?
XO
I loved how you just hinted at the self-loathing, but didn't let it take over. The imagery and detail were just enough I could see the two of you sitting there. Wonderfully written.
I love the feeling of this, the imagery you evoke. I can taste that vodka, and yes, the last line, too. It's my favorite.
With the third paragraph, I'd go for simple: "I'd calculated everything: the pink lace bra, the strappy black sandals, the cherry red toenails, even the fresh tan." Or something like that.
Also, this: "I turned my smile up a notch, the brightness now vying a Vegas billboard." Something about this sentence doesn't work for me. Perhaps, "I forced my smile wider, aiming for 'Vegas billboard' instead of just bright."
I love that we think the forgiveness is going to come from his apology, but that it springs from you in the end, realizing that he'll never change, realizing that to let go is to forgive.
This was so well done; I really enjoyed it!
Nah. An attempt to make me look like I've moved on too. :)
Thank you! I'm so glad you were able to visualize the scene. That's one of my biggest challenges. :)
Thank you!!
Yeah the not-really-an-apology is, was, the worst. It was so...lame, you know? After all that, it was less of an apology, more of an excuse for his behaviour.
Yes! That third paragraph niggled at me and I wasn't sure why. It just seemed to go on and on...
And yeah...I'm not a fan of wrap-up lines myself and felt kinda dorky using one, but I think it worked for the self reflection aspect.
Of course, when I wrote it, for some reason, I pictured myself as an 80-year-old woman, taking a drag on a cigarette and swigging some vodka as I said it. And I don't smoke.
Thank you, friend!
I think he was just as uncomfortable as I was, but for different reasons. Perhaps he expected a scene? Or a clinging, crying woman? Don't know...
And it wouldn't have fit my personality. I'm not really a "shove it" person. Except in my head. Then I say it, in not nearly as nice words. ;)
I'm so glad you were drawn in! I'm really good with dialogue, it's the imagery that I struggle with.
Thank you!
Thank you! The thing is...I didn't know at the time how many women had been in that position. I wish I had. It would have really helped me get through it. At the time, I thought I was the only person who'd ever been that hurt.
Of course, I was also 22.
Toned? Dude, that was the last time in my life I was toned. And tanned. I'm usually soft and sun burned. :)
And yes! That dang third paragraph was killing me. It was like a fly that would not buzz off...just bugging. And I couldn't figure out how to fix it.
Is it cheating if I fix it now? lol
Thank you so much!!
Yes, yes, yes! That third paragraph was bugging me. I really like the way you phrased it...as if I was cataloging an inventory.
Is it cheating to change it now? :D
Fantastic post. Seriously, you have a knack.
Oh! You're so right! Forgiveness really does taste just like vodka
This was awesome! Stopping by for the first time from TRDC, and I'm glad I did.
The fact that he tossed out that remark so casually, so arrogantly, said so much about him. Asshat.
This was excellent. The paragraph about the goosebumps, and then disappearing when the big things happen? Perfect. The wording was great. The last part, about forgiveness tasting like Vodka? Fantastic. I loved this. You rock. ;)
You did such a good job of describing that brittle beauty that we can have as women when we put ourselves into emotional situation that we know we probably shouldn't be in that I was uncomfortable while reading this! You built the tension extremely well, with agonizing over what to wear, the vodka and wheat thin diet, wondering where the heat went, that I didn't know at first whether I wanted you to sleep with him, or for him to ask for get back together and you kick him in the teeth, or if he was the one for you.
These lines were so raw, harsh and true, 'I pushed down the question bubbling to my lips. I took another drink to cool the anger, to show that I didn't care, to play the game I hated.' That I did wonder if you were going to end up at you 'local' bar getting wasted because it is an awful feeling to find yourself doing/act in ways that you would normally make fun of.
Finally, I loved your send off because I felt like I could hear exactly the tone in your voice as you said it,
"We'll have to do this again," I said, lying."
On a personal note, god, doesn't it suck when you see the exes.
Wow! I felt the anger there! This one had me on the edge, girl. :)
Great post. You portrayed the ex-girlfriend perfectly. How you blocked saying all the things you really wanted and agonized over what to wear. I am glad you found forgiveness, but I wish you would have let him have it too. Sometimes, its better to take the high road, which I am still learning :)
All of the small details and nuances made me feel as if I were right in your shoes! I was uncomfortable and hopeful and anxious and disappointed and angry and then free.
Great detail and description. I felt like I was right there with you. The forced conversation, each one of you wishing it was over. And the final lie. Why do we always do that? Wouldn't it be great to just say F-U. Buh bye. But we never do.
Girl, you've got writing skills that are downright amazing. This was an awesome piece of imagery and I loved every minute of it. Although...I kind of wish the energy and anger had turned into a punch rather than a smile LOL
I felt every single moment of this with you. I have just the guy I want to read it.
the last line told us everything with just a few words. I was blown away by the delivery and tone of this, I could have been sitting at that table. It was wonderful.
I can totally imagine this happening. You did a great job dealing with the emotion of the meeting--I felt like I was there with you.
I also really enjoyed the physical descriptions, including the new bra. Of course, you had a new one. Who wouldn't?
Your description of when you accept him for who he is was particularly piercing. I loved that.
This made me feel sick and emotional. I swear this story could have been about me. You did such a great job conveying the emotions, the uncomfort, the fake happy, the supressed anger. Wow. I really connected with this. Great job!!!!
This brought me to a place I haven't visited in years. You nailed it, from the intense analysis of everything, to the "planned speeches." I'm so thankful those days are behind me. Must thank my husband for marrying me :)
Personal note: Mandy, I don't know that I could have helped..this is wonderful.
The details you chose painted the picture, the emotion, the nerves and the anger. Well done.
I loved the truthfulness of this too. How often, when we've repeatedly bit back anger and pain that we allow ourselves to give into a moment of comfort.
She was one cool number!
Here is a question: is she forgiving herself, for wanting this guy. Or forgiving him for being a tool? Methinks the first.
Oooo I enjoyed the hell out of this. I was furious when he tossed that "apology" at you like a wet towel. Eff him if that's the best he's got. Your description of "faking it", of pretending to casually be over him even though you weren't, was fantastic. Who hasn't done that? Just great. And I LOVED that forgiveness tasted like vodka. I usually visit here for the fiction but this NF piece was brilliant!
I loved it. I love your last line especially. It's beautifully written. I felt like I was sitting right there watching. :)
well done! you captured the emotions of the scene perfectly. I was with you every step of the way. I have so been there and I even though I knew how the story might go, you led me right through it with ease. great job!
Thank you!
I'm so glad you were able to visualize the scene. Thank you for reading.
I think that's one of the things I enjoy about fiction. In fiction, your character can say eff you or the ex boyfriend can grovel. In real life, that doesn't usually happen.
I wish it was the first. Sadly, it was the second. It took a bit longer to get over him completely.
I think the exact. same. thing. Especially when my husband is being particularily annoying.
I'm so glad you connected. I think it's one of those situations that, while intensely personal, is also, to some extent, universal.
Rule number 1 when meeting an ex...always wear a new outfit and a new bra. We want to show him what he's missing.
I'm so very glad you enjoyed it.
LOL Do you know what's funny? If I were to fictionalize it, it probably would have. :)
I don't know why we don't do that. I've run into former friends, ex boyfriends, people who have hurt me and I always, always smile. And then wish I had said a buh-bye.
I'm so glad you enjoyed it. Thank you so much for reading!
Better, but I wonder if maybe not as satisfying. One of these days I want to take the low road, just to see...
Thank you so much!!
There was one horrible, horrible time when, at a friend's birthday party, various mutual friends invited not one, not two, but THREE of my exes. And not a single one of them had the decency to not show up.
Even more awful, I brought Chad as my date. So yes...all four of my current and former boyfriends. At the same table.
As for what I wanted to happen...I think it was a little of all of those things.
Thank you so much!!
Asshat indeed. But at least it's fodder for a memoir, right?
Thank you so much for stopping by and reading.
And sadness tastes like tequilla, rough and burning, hitting your stomach with a punch that makes you feel ill.
Love, of course, tastes like champagne. Bubbly and exciting with a hint of sweet and the power to knock you on your ass before you realize how much you've had.
Thank you. :)
I have a new favorite line, "I drank him in, cataloging the changes" that is perfection.
But I so hope that the dancing and wheat thins and what nots, wasn't just for this moment.
Very well done - you captured the feelings, the tone, the desperate effort spend in trying to look casual.
I especially like "I was the ideal ex-girlfriend, lightly flirting, no hint of desperation, teasing him about his dating life". I can't tell you how many times I've been that girl - not the ex, but a girl who can't get over a guy friend, who wants to be the fun friend he can talk to about those things. It's so painful and so difficult to pull off.
You wrapped it up very well. Right down to the lie - the sort of lie we all tell now and again. Good job.
It's always a sad, sad moment when you realize the flame has gone out. I feel you.
True. I'm working on a novel based loosely on my mom's mom and her
biological dad's life (mom was later adopted by my grandfather). I
have my grandma's diaries and have done a lot of researchon the 40s to
keep it feeling real but there is drama inherent in fiction that
healthy people try and keep out of their actual lives in much the way
your post describes.
I work full time and have 2 kids. When hubby and I were interviewing
nannies we had a line we used a lot, "We want all the drama in this
house on the page..." I really believe mental health is a pretty low
drama state but low drama fiction sucks.
I enjoy your blog and just joined. FYI, I keep my NF and F blogs
separated b/c one of my friends almost called 911 when she thought a
short story was real. : ) So when I post for TRDC Liar Liar Words on
Fire is my fiction blog and Honest Convo is my nonfiction blog.
People get confused on that. Be well!!
This was written so well. The descriptions, your attention to all the details. I have to admit, I was sure at first it was a memoir. And that is meant as a compliment!
I couldn't find anything that nudged at me.
And you handled that situation very well, by the way.
I love this piece. My favorite - "He wrapped his arms around me, enveloping me in his scent and sending years of memories to drown me." The detail was superb. I felt like I was right there at dinner and walking to the car with you.
I agree with NanyaDub, that was the line that choked me. Been there. wow. Thank you for linking up with this!!!
Post a Comment